This was my first tunic, but I have about 15 of the Proper and Wayward shirts. I love it! I thought it was light blue in the plaid, but it's grey, which is still really nice. I'm a cool soft summer, and this shirt looks awesome on me. I'm 5'4.5" so on the short side, and I love the length. I'm not into tunics, and I don't have any others, but I love this one, and might get more in the future. POMP is the bomb when it comes to shirts. Oh, and the fabric is ultra soft and cozy. I have another cotton/cashmere POMP (proper fit) shirt, the light grey with charcoal grid from maybe 2 yrs ago, and it's my fave flannel wise. I got the XS tunic for a relaxed not oversized fit. The size charts are spot on, along with the tip about sizing on the Wayward style. I wasn't even into plain shirts until I discovered POMP a few years ago. CS is also super!